“Once in a LIVEtime” was released in 1998.
This would start a trend with Dream Theater that after each studio album, a live album would follow from the tour. Kevin Shirley was on hand to produce and record it. But Shirley was stressed as he only had two days to mix and fix it. In the book “Lifting Shadows” by Rich Wilson, Shirley mentioned that on this live album there were a lot of fixes.
The show was recorded at the Bataclan Theater in Paris however the tour began September 1997 in Brazil. And before it even started, they had to get new management. Remember the manager who won the battle to remain manager, well he left. He wasn’t feeling it anymore. The management team that came in proved so much worse. The band was lost and needed direction. These new guys didn’t provide it, but they had no problem spending money. And when the band fired them the managers sued em.
Furthermore, Petrucci and Portnoy were at loggerheads. Portnoy still had a chip on his shoulder over Petrucci choosing to go with Shirley’s ideas and the disagreements they had over which manager would get the gig. During the tour, Portnoy even fired Petrucci’s guitar tech, which didn’t go down well with Petrucci.
Portnoy also announced to the band that he is quitting once the tour is finished. So in retrospect this live album could have been the last official release.
The album cover, one of two designed by Storm Thorgerson for the band, shows an overhead view of the ancient Roman theatre in Orange, France set into a head of a monk. Like “Falling into Infinity” it does not feature the band’s word mark due to Storm’s demand who sees logos as ugly.
This would also be the last album to feature Derek Sherinian on keyboards as his short tenure in the band would come to an end.
A Change of Seasons I: The Crimson Sunrise
So from a concert perspective, they split “A Change Of Seasons” into its separate parts and scattered them throughout the concert.
The acoustic intro gets the crowd singing along, ala Maiden like. Trust the Europeans (and the South Americans) to give a concert a football (soccer) like atmosphere. As soon as the band kicks in, its heavy and precise.
A Change of Seasons II: Innocence
They move into part 2 effortlessly. LaBrie is strained but does a great job. He’s a professional. Sometimes singers have 10 from 10 performances and some days they have 7 from 10. It’s still a good performance.
Puppies on Acid
Is basically “The Mirror” and a bit of “Lie” from the “Awake” album combined to serve as a segue into “Just Let Me Breathe”. Strange choice.
Just Let Me Breathe
From the “Falling To Infinity” album.
The song is great musically. I’m not a super fan of the vocal melodies, but I do like how they had the balls to try melodies like that.
One of my favourite tracks from the “Awake” album.
Press play to hear the intro, the way the Chorus crashes in musically and the excellent Petrucci solo. If anything, Petrucci’s playing live is even better than the studio recordings. He’s so precise, yet he still creates room for some improvisation. And that my friends is the meaning of a great musician.
LaBrie unfortunately is difficult to listen to, especially the high notes.
Take The Time
The first track from their biggest album so far, “Images and Words”.
Check out the funky first verses. You will feel like you are in the 70’s. It’s the beauty of the band, to be so diverse musically.
The ending contains the solo from Lynyrd Skynyrd’s “Freebird” and the main riff from Led Zeppelin’s “Moby Dick”. This is the kind of improvisation I like.
Derek Sherinian Piano Solo
I hate individual solo spotlights without any backing music to it.
For the purists, the brief solo does contain portions of “Platt Opus” which would be released on the debut Platypus album, (a progressive rock supergroup to which Sherinian and John Myung were members of, and they released their first album a year after this album).
However Sherinian tries to make his solo spotlight tie in with “Lines In The Sand”.
Lines In The Sand
From the “Falling into Infinity” album.
This song works live and LaBrie doesn’t need to strain his voice here as this song is more in the lower registers.
Petrucci again delivers a killer a guitar solo. All the emotion he committed to tape is here, live. The bends, the vibrato and the fast legato lines. Even Labrie at the end, mentioned, “John Petrucci on guitar people”.
The solo segues into my favourite part of the song. A groove is established and LaBrie is in his Pete Gabriel element here. Petrucci decorates like Alex Lifeson on the guitar. Then at 9.36, Petrucci starts to build it up, taking parts of the intro, and adding a lot of grease and blues. Then his Lifeson decorating with power chords and ringing open strings is back. Portnoy gets busier and the band cranks into the main riff of the song.
From the “Awake” album.
Ballsy move to play another epic track straight after an epic track, but then again, Dream Theater didn’t get to this stage, playing by the rules.
A Change of Seasons IV: The Darkest of Winters
And this is a perfect example of not playing by the rules. When they go into the instrumental section of “A Change Of Seasons”
And after 3 minutes of “The Darkest Of Winters”, they go into their instrumental masterpiece from “When Dream and Day Unite”, the “Majesty” spelt backwards “Ytse Jam”. And as soon as the intro riff kicks in, the crowd is chanting along with them.
This kind of set list is preaching to the converted.
Mike Portnoy Drum Solo
A 5 minute drum solo and the last 2 minutes is the ending of “Ytse Jam”.
But it’s a next for me.
Trial of Tears
From the “Falling into Infinity” album. The first two minutes has Petrucci playing “Close Encounters Of The Third Kind”, with Portnoy channelling Neal Peart from Rush.
From the “Falling Into Infinity” album.
The “Live At Budokan” version is the definitive version for me. The flamenco Al DiMeola like noodling at the start which is present on the “Budokan” version is here as well, just a bit more embryonic. And the solo sticks to script here, it doesn’t have the long shred solo from “Budokan”.
LaBrie doesn’t need to strain much here, and vocally he’s bringing it.
Take Away My Pain
From the “Falling into Infinity” album. I didn’t think it would end up in a set list as it’s not one of the stronger songs from the album.
Caught in a Web
From the “Awake” album. The tempo is sped up just a little bit and it works perfectly. You can feel the energy hit you from the speakers.
From the “Awake” album. Like “Caught In A Web” before it, the tempo is sped up a little bit and its perfect for the song. It sounds more energetic and powerful.
From the “Falling into Infinity” album and the band definitely shows which songs influenced the song as they go into portions of “Have a Cigar” from Pink Floyd and “Enter Sandman” from Metallica. Press play to hear it.
John Petrucci Guitar Solo
An 8 minute guitar solo which contains a portion of a song that would become “Paradigm Shift” from a side project called “Liquid Tension Experiment”, which Portnoy and Petrucci would form after this period with future Dream Theater keyboardist Jordan Rudess and bassist Tony Levin.
The ending of the album begins with “Pull Me Under”, “Metropolis” and “Learning To Live”. My three favourite songs from “Images And Words”. And they finish it off how they started, with the final chapter of “A Change Of Seasons”.
For a live album, it is the least favourite live album in the “Dream Theater” catalogue. I don’t go back to it much, however as the title states, it’s a capture of a time, a period. So enjoy it for what it is, a band on the verge of breaking up but keeping it all together for their love of music.
And a DVD release came out as well. But that review is for another day.
2 thoughts on “The Record Vault: Dream Theater – Once In A Livetime”
Considering I love live albums I have never bought any live DT… I should at least get one….lol
Live At Budokan. It can go next to your Cheap Trick one. Wink wink.