There’s a 1962 rock song called “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love)” that most people probably haven’t thought about in decades.
Depending on your age, you might remember the Swingin’ Medallions version, or like me, you might have to ask Spotify. After I heard it, I remember George Thorogood and The Cockroaches (from Australia) did versions of this song.
For the trivia buffs, Tony Field and Jeff Fatt formed “The Wiggles” after The Cockroaches disbanded and made more money than they either would or could have as a label artist.
And the song is now sitting in the middle of a fight that could change the economics of the entire entertainment business.
Somebody wants their copyright back. And the music industry would prefer that they didn’t.
I came across this story in Forbes, in an article titled “Rock Song Copyright Dispute Rocks The Entertainment Industry,” published October 9, 2026. Read the full article here.
In 1963, Don Smith and Cyril Vetter assigned the copyright to “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love)” to Windsong Music Publishers. The deal covered the song worldwide for the full term of copyright protection.
That was the business.
You wrote the song. Somebody else handled everything else. You received whatever your agreement entitled you to receive.
Everybody went home.
Except that in the music business, going home doesn’t necessarily mean the money stops coming.
A song can outlive its creators. It can outlive the record company that released it, the publisher that acquired it, the executives who negotiated the contracts and the original audience that bought the records.
It can become a catalogue asset. And catalogue assets are now serious business.
Investors buy catalogues, publishers consolidate ownership, and companies calculate future royalty streams.
The song becomes an asset. The asset generates cash. The cash flow gets valued, packaged and sold.
Somewhere along the way, the person who wrote the song becomes the least interesting part of the transaction.
And that’s the problem.
What happens when an agreement made decades ago becomes an increasingly valuable claim on the future.
And the original creator wants to exercise a right that the law specifically gave them to get that property back.
Under US copyright law, eligible authors and their heirs can terminate certain earlier grants of copyright after a specified period.
Artists signed contracts before anyone knew whether their work will be commercially successful. The law provides a mechanism for some of those rights to return to the creator or their successors.
Imagine that.
You sign away your rights when you’re young, inexperienced or desperate to get a deal. Time passes. The work proves valuable. Eventually, you may have an opportunity to reclaim what you previously assigned.
It’s an attempt to rebalance the relationship.
In the “Double Shot” dispute, Cyril Vetter sent a termination notice in 2019 seeking to reclaim rights he had assigned in 1963. 56 years ago.
The fight isn’t simply about whether he can get his rights back. It’s about how far those rights extend.
For decades, the understanding was that termination under US law affected American rights, while foreign rights remained governed by the original grant and the applicable laws overseas.
But.
In January 2026, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals took a different view in Vetter v. Resnik, holding that the termination could reclaim worldwide rights.
If a US termination can recover rights internationally, a contract that publishers thought would continue generating foreign revenue may no longer mean what they thought it meant.
Major record companies and BMG are now pushing for the US Supreme Court to review the decision.
As the Forbes article explains, the dispute has attracted heavyweight interests from across entertainment, including the Motion Picture Association and Paramount Pictures. This isn’t just about a forgotten rock song. The same legal principles could affect other copyright-based industries, from books and screenplays to photography and art.
The Supreme Court has not yet agreed to hear the case. The Fifth Circuit ruling applies within its jurisdiction, covering Louisiana, Texas and Mississippi, and its broader consequences remain uncertain.
But the reaction tells you something.
The industry is worried about the precedent.
And when an industry starts warning that the rules might change, it’s worth asking who benefited from the old rules.
Follow the money. Then follow the outrage.
The labels and publishers aren’t necessarily making a ridiculous point when they warn about instability. A ruling that changes the interpretation of decades-old agreements could affect catalogue valuations, international licensing and existing commercial arrangements. Investors price risk, and legal uncertainty can make transactions more expensive or less attractive.
Paramount’s concerns about disruption are real commercial concerns, not just corporate theatre.
But commercial disruption is not the same thing as injustice.
An industry can become accustomed to a particular interpretation of the law. It can build its contracts around that interpretation. It can even spend billions of dollars buying assets whose value depends on that interpretation.
None of those things automatically makes the interpretation correct.
And none of them necessarily means the law should be changed to protect the investments made under it.
The music business has spent decades telling artists that contracts matter. That the paperwork is binding. That the rights were assigned. That the deal was the deal.
Now the possibility exists that a court might interpret those contracts and the statute differently from the way the industry expected. Suddenly, the paperwork needs saving.
Funny that.
I’ve spent enough time listening to records, reading credits and following bands to know that the public and the music industry don’t always value the same things.
I remember the riff. The chorus. But. I don’t generally remember who administered the publishing.
I don’t know which company owns the foreign rights.
But those things matter to someone.
A song and a recording are different assets. The songwriter creates the composition: the music and lyrics. The recording is a particular recorded performance of that composition. They can have different owners, different contracts and different revenue streams.
The “Double Shot” dispute concerns the termination of a grant involving the song’s copyright. It is not, by itself, a general ruling that performers can take ownership of their old master recordings.
Different creators face different contractual histories, and not every artist can use termination rights to recover every asset they once signed away.
Look at the other disputes mentioned in Forbes.
Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster’s heirs fought over Superman, a character sold in the early days of the comic-book industry for a tiny fraction of the value it would eventually generate. In 2008, a federal court allowed termination in part but limited the recovery to domestic rights.
Salt-N-Pepa sued Universal Music Group in 2025 seeking to reclaim rights connected to their recordings, including “Push It.” A judge dismissed their case in January 2026, finding that the duo had not owned the relevant copyrights under their original arrangement. They have appealed.
I would like to add the following disputes.
The Jesus and Mary Chain served Warner Music with termination notices in 2019, seeking to regain rights to their early recordings, only to have the label dispute their claim. The band took the matter to court, eventually settling in 2023, although the terms remained confidential.
John Waite, the former Babys and Bad English frontman, went down a similar road with Universal Music Group, joining other recording artists in challenging the label’s refusal to recognise their termination notices. That litigation also ended in a settlement in 2023.
Duran Duran’s battle with Sony Music raised a related question: who actually owns the value created by a band’s back catalogue? In 2023, the British group won a UK High Court ruling in a dispute with Gloucester Place Music, part of Sony Music Publishing, over the interpretation of contractual provisions relating to their songwriting royalties.
The case involved the band’s attempt to rely on US copyright termination rights and the interaction between those rights and their publishing agreements.
It is important to distinguish this from a straightforward claim to reclaim master recordings: the Duran Duran dispute centred on music publishing and contractual interpretation, rather than simply recovering ownership of the original studio tapes.
These cases expose the tension at the heart of the recording business: labels treat old contracts as enduring commercial assets, while artists see copyright termination as a chance to regain control of work they created decades ago.
There’s another reason this fight matters: the music industry has changed the way it thinks about the past.
Once upon a time, a record company needed a new band. It needed songs. It took risks on artists who might fail and hoped that the successful ones would generate enough money to cover the unsuccessful ones.
Today, the established catalogue has become one of the industry’s most attractive assets.
The hits already exist. The audience already exists. They can be streamed, synchronised to film and television, licensed for advertising and introduced to new generations.
The revenue may fluctuate.
You are buying an existing relationship between a song and its audience. And because that relationship can last for generations, the rights can be extraordinarily valuable.
The major publishers are optimising for certainty. That’s understandable. Their business depends on knowing what they own, what they can license and what their investments are worth.
Songwriter advocates are optimising for something else: meaningful control over creative work, including the ability to exercise statutory rights that might otherwise be worth less than they appear on paper.
Both sides can argue that they’re protecting the future of the industry.
Artists need good publishers. Writers need people who can get their work heard, licensed and paid for. Investment can help bring old music to new audiences.
But the relationship works best when the deal is transparent and the rights of each party are understood.
If the industry believes worldwide termination creates unacceptable uncertainty, it should make that case on the law’s merits. If creators believe the established interpretation denied them rights Congress intended them to have, they should be able to make that case, too.
The fact that one side has billions of dollars riding on the outcome doesn’t settle the question.
It just explains why that side cares so much.
Here’s what interests me most.
The ruling could encourage more artists and songwriters to investigate termination rights. It could prompt publishers to revisit contracts and catalogue valuations. It could lead to new licensing arrangements designed to reduce the uncertainty.
Or the Supreme Court could decline to hear the case, leaving the Fifth Circuit ruling in place for now. Other courts could reach different conclusions. Congress could eventually intervene.
Nobody knows how this plays out.
But the industry has already received a message: a catalogue isn’t necessarily as secure as the person holding the spreadsheet believes it is.
It does mean that creators should understand what they signed, what they own and what rights may become available as time passes.
And it means that publishers and labels should stop treating historical assumptions as if they were eternal truths.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth about the music business.
The older a song gets, the easier it becomes to forget that somebody had to write it. The song becomes a line in a portfolio.
But somebody sat down and wrote “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love)” in 1962. Somebody created the thing that all those contracts, licences and valuations are built around.
That doesn’t mean the songwriter should automatically own every right forever. Copyright law has limits, and commercial partners have legitimate interests. The original agreement matters.
But the creator shouldn’t become irrelevant simply because the industry has found increasingly sophisticated ways to monetise the work.
The labels see billions of dollars of potential disruption. The songwriters see rights that may have been theirs to reclaim all along.
Both are looking at the same catalogue. They’re just seeing different things.
And perhaps that’s the point.
The music business has always been good at turning yesterday’s creativity into tomorrow’s revenue. The question is whether it can do that without treating the people who created yesterday’s music as a historical inconvenience.
A song can last forever.
A contract shouldn’t have to be interpreted as though the people who signed it, the circumstances in which they signed it and the laws governing it can never change.
For now, the Supreme Court has yet to decide whether it will take up Vetter v. Resnik. The outcome could shape how publishers, labels, creators and investors think about copyright ownership for years to come.
Until then, I’ll leave you with this:
The music industry has spent decades telling artists that their work is an asset.
Now some artists want the asset back. Suddenly, everybody wants to talk about the fine print.